I'm a sucker for psycological thrillers/suspense movies. The twistier, the better. Hubbie and I watched Number 23 tonight (only thing in the Red Box that he would agree to), and it was pretty good. It's scary enough to just see Jim Carey not in a "funny" role, but then add in lots of twists and a good amount of sex and blood and some numerology and it makes for an interesting view!
I remember when it came out in theaters it received relatively bad reviews from critics. So when my sister asked me to watch it, I expected the worst. However, I was pleasantly surprised... I loved it. Jim Carey is one of my favorite actors. Have you seen him in Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind? He was awesome in that too. He has really been taking on more difficult and complex characters.
Another great one is the Truman Show. I had to study that one in my film class.
I loved Eternal Sunshine! I need to rent it again-it was such a wild concept and Jim Carrey was great in it!